conversion of succinate to propanoate
MetaCyc:PWY0-43
The Sbm/ScpABC three-enzyme biochemical cycle annotated for Escherichia coli K-12 MG1655 couples succinyl-CoA rearrangement, methylmalonyl-CoA decarboxylation and CoA transfer to succinate. Adenosylcobalamin supports Sbm mutase activity. Recombinant enzyme assays support the proposed cycle, but do not establish wild-type pathway flux. The graph retains the current reviewed Rhea/UniProt assignment of (R)-methylmalonyl-CoA to ScpB as an annotation with unresolved experimental stereospecificity: the original coupled assay did not resolve the methylmalonyl-CoA enantiomers, while later engineered strains required a heterologous epimerase for propionate production from glucose in minimal medium. A later direct ScpB assay used an R/S substrate mixture and also observed hydrolysis. These findings remain a source conflict; no unverified native epimerase is added. The native Sbm dimer and ScpB hexamer are represented as assemblies; apo-Sbm can also occur as a monomer.
- Pathway type
- proposed succinate decarboxylation cycle
- Organism scope
Pathway network
17 nodes · 22 asserted directed edges
Arrows show recorded subject → object relationships, not necessarily metabolic flow. Select a node for details or an arrow for evidence. Scroll, zoom or find a node to explore.
- Reaction / activity
- Chemical / cofactor
- Protein / complex
- Pathway
- Solid arrow: mechanistic relation
- Dashed arrow: membership, location or cofactor relation
Components and activities
| Node | Kind or role | Source direction |
|---|---|---|
Escherichia coli str. K-12 substr. MG1655NCBITaxon:511145 | taxon | |
succinate(2-)CHEBI:30031 | small molecule | |
succinyl-CoA(5-)CHEBI:57292 | small molecule | |
(R)-methylmalonyl-CoA(5-)CHEBI:57326 | small molecule | |
propionyl-CoA(4-)CHEBI:57392 | small molecule | |
propionateCHEBI:17272 | small molecule | |
hydronCHEBI:15378 | small molecule | |
carbon dioxideCHEBI:16526 | small molecule | |
cobamamideCHEBI:18408 | cofactor | |
Methylmalonyl-CoA mutaseUniProtKB:P27253 | protein | |
Methylmalonyl-CoA decarboxylaseUniProtKB:P52045 | protein | |
Propanoyl-CoA:succinate CoA transferaseUniProtKB:P52043 | protein | |
methylmalonyl-CoA mutaseMetaCyc:CPLX0-7741 | complex | |
methylmalonyl-CoA decarboxylaseMetaCyc:CPLX0-254 | complex | |
succinyl-CoA => (R)-methylmalonyl-CoARHEA:22890 | molecular activity | right to left |
(R)-methylmalonyl-CoA + H(+) => propanoyl-CoA + CO2RHEA:27667 | molecular activity | left to right |
propanoyl-CoA + succinate => propanoate + succinyl-CoARHEA:28011 | molecular activity | left to right |
Mechanistic edges
| Subject | Predicate and description | Object | Evidence |
|---|---|---|---|
succinyl-CoA(5-)CHEBI:57292 | consumes | succinyl-CoA => (R)-methylmalonyl-CoARHEA:22890 |
|
succinyl-CoA => (R)-methylmalonyl-CoARHEA:22890 | produces | (R)-methylmalonyl-CoA(5-)CHEBI:57326 |
|
(R)-methylmalonyl-CoA(5-)CHEBI:57326 | consumes This is the current Rhea/UniProt (R)-specific annotation, not an enantiomer-resolved ScpB assay. PMID:28716098 reports epimerase dependence in engineered glucose/minimal-medium cultures. The conflict with the original coupled assay remains unresolved; no wild-type flux is asserted. | (R)-methylmalonyl-CoA + H(+) => propanoyl-CoA + CO2RHEA:27667 |
|
hydronCHEBI:15378 | consumes This is the current Rhea/UniProt (R)-specific annotation, not an enantiomer-resolved ScpB assay. PMID:28716098 reports epimerase dependence in engineered glucose/minimal-medium cultures. The conflict with the original coupled assay remains unresolved; no wild-type flux is asserted. | (R)-methylmalonyl-CoA + H(+) => propanoyl-CoA + CO2RHEA:27667 |
|
(R)-methylmalonyl-CoA + H(+) => propanoyl-CoA + CO2RHEA:27667 | produces This is the current Rhea/UniProt (R)-specific annotation, not an enantiomer-resolved ScpB assay. PMID:28716098 reports epimerase dependence in engineered glucose/minimal-medium cultures. The conflict with the original coupled assay remains unresolved; no wild-type flux is asserted. | propionyl-CoA(4-)CHEBI:57392 |
|
(R)-methylmalonyl-CoA + H(+) => propanoyl-CoA + CO2RHEA:27667 | produces This is the current Rhea/UniProt (R)-specific annotation, not an enantiomer-resolved ScpB assay. PMID:28716098 reports epimerase dependence in engineered glucose/minimal-medium cultures. The conflict with the original coupled assay remains unresolved; no wild-type flux is asserted. | carbon dioxideCHEBI:16526 |
|
propionyl-CoA(4-)CHEBI:57392 | consumes | propanoyl-CoA + succinate => propanoate + succinyl-CoARHEA:28011 |
|
succinate(2-)CHEBI:30031 | consumes | propanoyl-CoA + succinate => propanoate + succinyl-CoARHEA:28011 |
|
propanoyl-CoA + succinate => propanoate + succinyl-CoARHEA:28011 | produces | propionateCHEBI:17272 |
|
propanoyl-CoA + succinate => propanoate + succinyl-CoARHEA:28011 | produces | succinyl-CoA(5-)CHEBI:57292 |
|
Methylmalonyl-CoA mutaseUniProtKB:P27253 | part_of Membership represents the annotated Sbm homodimer; it does not imply that all apo-Sbm is dimeric or include the distinct YgfD-bound assembly. | methylmalonyl-CoA mutaseMetaCyc:CPLX0-7741 |
|
Methylmalonyl-CoA decarboxylaseUniProtKB:P52045 | part_of | methylmalonyl-CoA decarboxylaseMetaCyc:CPLX0-254 |
|
methylmalonyl-CoA mutaseMetaCyc:CPLX0-7741 | catalyzes RHEA:22890 selects the succinyl-CoA-to-(R)-methylmalonyl-CoA direction of the reversible mutase reaction for the proposed cycle. | succinyl-CoA => (R)-methylmalonyl-CoARHEA:22890 |
|
methylmalonyl-CoA decarboxylaseMetaCyc:CPLX0-254 | catalyzes This is the current Rhea/UniProt (R)-specific annotation, not an enantiomer-resolved ScpB assay. PMID:28716098 reports epimerase dependence in engineered glucose/minimal-medium cultures. The conflict with the original coupled assay remains unresolved; no wild-type flux is asserted. The 2019 assay used an R/S substrate mixture. | (R)-methylmalonyl-CoA + H(+) => propanoyl-CoA + CO2RHEA:27667 |
|
Propanoyl-CoA:succinate CoA transferaseUniProtKB:P52043 | catalyzes RHEA:28011 selects the propionyl-CoA plus succinate direction of a reversible CoA transferase reaction; ScpC is represented by its protein identifier without an unsupported oligomeric state. | propanoyl-CoA + succinate => propanoate + succinyl-CoARHEA:28011 |
|
Methylmalonyl-CoA mutaseUniProtKB:P27253 | has_cofactor CHEBI:18408 has canonical ChEBI label cobamamide; this is adenosylcobalamin, not a generic vitamin B12 pool or a consumed pathway substrate. | cobamamideCHEBI:18408 |
|
succinyl-CoA => (R)-methylmalonyl-CoARHEA:22890 | part_of Membership in the experimentally motivated biochemical proposal does not assert operation of a complete native cycle under unspecified growth conditions. | MetaCyc:PWY0-43 |
|
(R)-methylmalonyl-CoA + H(+) => propanoyl-CoA + CO2RHEA:27667 | part_of Membership in the experimentally motivated biochemical proposal does not assert operation of a complete native cycle under unspecified growth conditions. | MetaCyc:PWY0-43 |
|
propanoyl-CoA + succinate => propanoate + succinyl-CoARHEA:28011 | part_of Membership in the experimentally motivated biochemical proposal does not assert operation of a complete native cycle under unspecified growth conditions. | MetaCyc:PWY0-43 |
|
succinyl-CoA => (R)-methylmalonyl-CoARHEA:22890 | provides_input_for This is the current Rhea/UniProt (R)-specific annotation, not an enantiomer-resolved ScpB assay. PMID:28716098 reports epimerase dependence in engineered glucose/minimal-medium cultures. The conflict with the original coupled assay remains unresolved; no wild-type flux is asserted. | (R)-methylmalonyl-CoA + H(+) => propanoyl-CoA + CO2RHEA:27667 |
|
(R)-methylmalonyl-CoA + H(+) => propanoyl-CoA + CO2RHEA:27667 | provides_input_for This edge records the native biochemical-cycle layout, not measured wild-type flux or an additional physiological inference. | propanoyl-CoA + succinate => propanoate + succinyl-CoARHEA:28011 |
|
propanoyl-CoA + succinate => propanoate + succinyl-CoARHEA:28011 | provides_input_for This edge records the native biochemical-cycle layout, not measured wild-type flux or an additional physiological inference. | succinyl-CoA => (R)-methylmalonyl-CoARHEA:22890 |
|
References
MetaCyc:PWY0-43MetaCyc PWY0-43 (source version: 22.5; official mirror retrieved 2026-10-10)MetaCyc:CPLX0-7741MetaCyc CPLX0-7741 (source version: 22.5; official mirror retrieved 2026-10-10)MetaCyc:CPLX0-254MetaCyc CPLX0-254 (source version: 22.5; official mirror retrieved 2026-10-10)MetaCyc:METHYLMALONYL-COA-MUT-MONOMERMetaCyc METHYLMALONYL-COA-MUT-MONOMER (source version: 22.5; official mirror retrieved 2026-10-10)MetaCyc:G7516-MONOMERMetaCyc G7516-MONOMER (source version: 22.5; official mirror retrieved 2026-10-10)MetaCyc:G7517-MONOMERMetaCyc G7517-MONOMER (source version: 22.5; official mirror retrieved 2026-10-10)MetaCyc:METHYLMALONYL-COA-MUT-RXNMetaCyc METHYLMALONYL-COA-MUT-RXN (source version: 22.5; official mirror retrieved 2026-10-10)MetaCyc:RXN0-310MetaCyc RXN0-310 (source version: 22.5; official mirror retrieved 2026-10-10)MetaCyc:RXN0-268MetaCyc RXN0-268 (source version: 22.5; official mirror retrieved 2026-10-10)UniProtKB:P27253Reviewed UniProtKB P27253 (source version: 2026_03; retrieved 2026-10-10)UniProtKB:P52045Reviewed UniProtKB P52045 (source version: 2026_03; retrieved 2026-10-10)UniProtKB:P52043Reviewed UniProtKB P52043 (source version: 2026_03; retrieved 2026-10-10)RHEA:22890Rhea 22890 directional reaction (source version: 142 (2026-09-02))RHEA:27667Rhea 27667 directional reaction (source version: 142 (2026-09-02))RHEA:28011Rhea 28011 directional reaction (source version: 142 (2026-09-02))PMID:10769117Discovering new enzymes and metabolic pathways: conversion of succinate to propionate by Escherichia coli. (source version: Primary full text; DOI 10.1021/bi992888d; retrieved 2026-10-10)PMID:18950999Sleeping beauty mutase (sbm) is expressed and interacts with ygfD in Escherichia coli. (source version: Primary full text; retrieved 2026-10-10)PMID:10769118New reactions in the crotonase superfamily: structure of methylmalonyl CoA decarboxylase from Escherichia coli. (source version: Europe PMC core metadata and complete indexed abstract; retrieved 2026-10-10)PMID:28716098Awakening sleeping beauty: production of propionic acid in Escherichia coli through the sbm operon requires the activity of a methylmalonyl-CoA epimerase. (source version: Primary full text; retrieved 2026-10-10)DOI:10.1021/jacs.9b00650.s001Supporting Information: Sulfonate/Nitro Bearing Methylmalonyl-Thioester Isosteres Applied to Methylmalonyl-CoA Decarboxylase Structure-Function Studies. (source version: ACS Figshare article 7863569, file 14641211; retrieved 2026-10-10)
Curation history
- codex
- CREATE — Add the proposed Sbm/ScpABC cycle with explicit stereochemistry and physiological limits
Curated MetaCyc:PWY0-43 using native MetaCyc, reviewed UniProt, directed Rhea and inspected primary studies including the 2019 supporting information. Retains three reactions, two native assemblies, adenosylcobalamin and 22 edges with 38 evidence blocks. Native/closed schema, independently verified identities, ten Rhea chemical edges, elemental/charge balance, net chemistry and twenty reference hashes passed author checks. Independent review found an incorrect apo-Sbm source locator; issue324 corrects it to Results Interaction of YgfD and Sbm in vitro, Figure4B and Figure4C panel2. R/S assay ambiguity and later engineered-strain epimerase dependence remain explicit. No native epimerase, sodium/biotin requirement or wild-type flux is asserted. Full-corpus gates, graph export verification and final independent review are documented separately.
- CREATE — Add the proposed Sbm/ScpABC cycle with explicit stereochemistry and physiological limits